Counting to five revealed how children’s inner speech develops: 5 conclusions

Researchers assessed the development of inner speech in children aged 3–6 by asking them to count simply from one to five. Around the age of five, the children’s ability to perform the task entirely in their heads became noticeably more consistent.
Internal speech develops gradually in children: in a new study, mental counting became more consistent with age, and by around five years of age, children were noticeably more consistent in completing the task entirely in their heads — without using their voice or moving their lips or fingers.
The study, published in *Acta Psychologica*, involved 58 children aged 3–6 and 25 adults. The study does not establish a universal age for the emergence of the ‘inner voice’ and is not a diagnostic test: the authors measured a specific ability — how consistently a participant could count from one to five in their head.
Details
Participants counted from one to five aloud five times and silently five more times, whilst trying to maintain a consistent pace. The researchers compared the variation in the time intervals between repetitions. The lower the variation, the more consistently the task was performed.
1. Counting silently proved to be less consistent than counting aloud
Across all age groups, the timing of mental counting fluctuated more than that of counting aloud. The authors attribute this to the lack of external sensory feedback: during normal speech, a person hears their own voice and receives additional cues that help them maintain a rhythm.
2. In children, silent counting became more consistent with age
The main age-related effect was observed specifically in the silent counting condition. Among older pre-schoolers, the variation in time between attempts decreased, whereas no such pronounced age-related pattern was observed when counting aloud. This suggests a gradual stabilisation of internal counting, rather than simply an improvement in counting skills.
3. Around the age of five, a benchmark for consistent mental counting emerged
The researchers recorded separately whether a child was able to complete the task without vocalisation and without noticeable movements of the lips or fingers. Children who were able to switch entirely to mental counting were, on average, older. In the study data, the age of around five years emerged as an important milestone when this ability becomes more stable.
This does not mean that internal speech does not exist before the age of five, or that every child must demonstrate it on a specific birthday. The study describes a general pattern within a small sample, and individual children may develop at different rates.
4. Children may use inner speech before they are able to explain it
Participants were also asked whether people could use words ‘in their heads’ without saying them out loud. Adults were significantly more likely to clearly understand this idea. In children, answers to such questions were not linked to the results of mental arithmetic.
The authors interpret this as a sign that a child may already be using inner speech but does not yet possess sufficient metacognitive ability to confidently describe their own inner experience.
5. Counting to five could be a simple way to study inner speech
The method does not require brain scans or complex memory tasks. This is potentially useful for research involving pre-school children, who find it difficult to describe what is happening ‘in their heads’. The authors propose that variations in the time taken to count serve as a sensitive indicator of the maturation of inner speech.
For now, this is a research tool. The study does not suggest that counting to five at home can be used to assess developmental norms, diagnose speech disorders or draw conclusions about a child’s intelligence.
Why this is important
Internal speech is linked to attention, planning and self-control, but its early development is difficult to study precisely because young children are not yet able to describe their subjective experiences very well. This new approach allows us to observe age-related changes indirectly — through the stability of a simple mental action.
There are significant limitations: the study involved 58 children, compared different age groups at a single point in time and tested only one short task. It does not track the development of the same child over the years, nor does it prove that all forms of inner speech mature in the same way.
The practical implication for parents is limited: the findings do not establish a ‘standard timeframe’ and do not constitute grounds for parents to assess their child on their own. If there are genuine concerns about speech or behavioural development, these should be assessed by a specialist based on a combination of signs, rather than on the basis of a single experimental task.
Source
Kota Otani, Ryoichi Watanabe, Ryuta Kuwamizu, Nozomi Yamamoto, Yusuke Moriguchi, ‘The developmental origin of inner speech: Evidence from a mental counting task in 3- to 6-year-old children’, Acta Psychologica, 270, 107716 (2026).
Study description and authors’ comments: University of Tsukuba. Bibliographic record and abstract: PubMed.
- A Hawaiian bird with a ‘double’ beak pecks at a tree with its whole body - scientists have discovered how
- Why did the kings of Norway need Sámi ancestors? Historians have re-examined the sagas
- A fish with a transparent head was filmed in 4K at a depth of 600 metres
- Up to 107,000 wild species have been identified as being used or traded
- Genetic evidence of natural selection has been found in dogs near the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Station
- A link has been found between protein and the diversity of gut bacteria in vegans
Maria Grynevych, project manager, journalist, co-author of Guidebook Sacred Mountains of the Dnieper Region, Lecture Course: Cult Topography of the Middle Dnieper Region.













